Which Irvine condo community has the best swimming pool, fitness center, clubhouse or penthouse? And if a zombie apocalypse ever happened, which high-rise would be the safest place to hide?
We decided to have a little fun with these questions. Filming from the lobby of Lexington at Central Park West in Irvine, Edwin Baloloy and Kathy Jimenez of MidRise Living drew random cards and debated which Orange County condo communities deserved to win each category.
Our comparisons included Avenue One, Watermarke, Lexington at Central Park West, Marquee at Park Place, The Plaza, 3000 The Plaza, Skyline OC and 601 Lido Park Drive. Although most are in Irvine, Skyline OC is technically in Santa Ana, while 601 Lido Park is in Newport Beach. See our Irvine condo directory here.
Here are the results of our Irvine Condo Showdown.
Best Parking
Our picks: Watermarke and Avenue One, Irvine
Both communities offer assigned resident parking along with access to a large parking garage that makes short-term guest visits relatively convenient. For owners who frequently entertain visitors, having plenty of available guest parking can be a significant advantage.
Kathy also pointed out the opposite experience at Skyline OC, where finding convenient parking can be challenging, particularly with nearby construction and restrictions on surrounding parking spaces.
Most Affordable
Our pick: Watermarke, Irvine
Watermarke and Avenue One are among the more affordable condominium options in the Irvine Business Complex, particularly for buyers seeking smaller one-bedroom residences.
We ultimately leaned toward Watermarke, where smaller units were discussed in the mid-$500,000 range. However, HOA dues can be higher than at Avenue One, potentially narrowing the difference in overall monthly ownership costs.
For first-time buyers, both communities offer an opportunity to enter the Irvine condo market without purchasing a larger luxury high-rise residence.
Best Walkability
Our pick: Lexington at Central Park West, Irvine
Lexington benefits from its proximity to Park Place, where residents can walk to Mother’s Market, Houston’s, restaurants, fitness facilities and other neighborhood conveniences.
Marquee at Park Place enjoys many of these same advantages, but we gave Lexington the edge because of its location within Central Park West and the planned pedestrian bridge connecting the area.
For residents who prefer leaving their cars parked and walking to everyday destinations, Lexington is a compelling choice.
Highest HOA Dues
Our pick: 601 Lido Park Drive, Newport Beach
This category wasn’t particularly close. During our discussion, we estimated HOA dues at 601 Lido Park at approximately $2,100 to $2,400 per month, depending on the residence.
That’s substantially higher than many of the Irvine luxury high-rise communities we compared. The Plaza, Marquee at Park Place and Skyline OC were among the other buildings discussed for their higher monthly HOA fees.
Of course, HOA dues should be evaluated alongside the amenities, services, maintenance responsibilities and overall lifestyle provided by each community.
Best Resort Feel
Our pick: 601 Lido Park Drive, Newport Beach
Kathy made a convincing argument for 601 Lido Park based on its waterfront surroundings and vacation-like atmosphere.
Imagine stepping outside your condominium and walking to waterfront dining, enjoying a lobster roll, or watching boats move through Newport Harbor. With harbor views on one side and ocean views nearby, the location feels more like a coastal getaway than a conventional condo development.
Central Park West offers impressive amenities of its own, but we agreed that the surrounding commercial environment gives it a more urban atmosphere.
For a true vacation-inspired lifestyle, 601 Lido Park took this category.
Best for Singles
Our picks: Avenue One, Irvine, and Skyline OC, Santa Ana
This category generated some interesting discussion.
Skyline OC has a reputation for an energetic residential atmosphere dating back to its earlier Essex era, while Avenue One offers a mix of residents and relatively accessible one-bedroom condo options.
Kathy also made a case for Lexington at Central Park West, especially for someone with a larger budget who values nearby restaurants and walkable date-night destinations.
Ultimately, Avenue One and Skyline OC were our leading choices for their social atmosphere and condo lifestyle, although Lexington would be an attractive alternative for someone prioritizing upscale surroundings and nearby dining.
Best Lobby
Our pick: 601 Lido Park Drive, Newport Beach
Marquee at Park Place and The Plaza both earned praise for their staffed lobbies and the welcoming experience provided by their attendants.
However, Edwin selected 601 Lido Park for its more intimate, carefully designed lobby and personalized arrival experience.
Unlike some of the larger high-rise buildings, 601 Lido Park has a boutique atmosphere. Its lobby feels elegant without being overwhelming, reinforcing the property’s coastal resort character.
Best Penthouses
Our picks: The Plaza, Irvine, and Skyline OC, Santa Ana
We disagreed on this one.
Edwin chose The Plaza, particularly for its dramatic two-story penthouse layout, soaring ceilings, expansive windows and open interior design. The sense of volume and architectural character makes these residences especially memorable.
Kathy preferred Skyline OC for its remarkable elevation and panoramic views. From the upper floors, the surrounding cityscape stretches for miles, creating a very different high-rise experience.
For Edwin, architectural design and ceiling height gave The Plaza the advantage. For Kathy, Skyline OC’s commanding views were difficult to beat.
Best for Surviving a Zombie Apocalypse
Our pick: Skyline OC, Santa Ana
This was easily our most unusual category.
We both gravitated toward Skyline OC because of its height, limited building entrances and the possibility of retreating to an upper-floor residence.
Naturally, we had to consider some practical zombie-movie problems. What happens when the elevators stop working? Could stairwells be barricaded? How would residents access water on the upper floors?
Lexington also entered the discussion as a possible refuge, but Skyline OC’s 27-story height ultimately won our imaginary survival challenge.
We’re hoping this is one category nobody ever needs to test.
Best Fitness Center
Our pick: Lexington at Central Park West, Irvine
Lexington was our clear choice for fitness amenities.
Central Park West offers two fitness facilities, including a larger main gym with extensive exercise equipment, a cycling room, and areas suitable for stretching and Pilates.
With 24-hour access and a wide selection of equipment, the main facility offers enough variety that many residents may find they no longer need a separate gym membership.
For buyers who prioritize fitness as part of their everyday lifestyle, Lexington deserves serious consideration.
Best Clubhouse
Our picks: Avenue One and Watermarke, Irvine
Kathy chose Avenue One because of its contemporary clubhouse and suitability for social gatherings. Having seen the space used for a baby shower, she appreciated how comfortably it accommodates community events and private celebrations.
Edwin preferred Watermarke for its more elaborate architectural design. Its two-story clubhouse features a sweeping staircase, library and European-inspired interior details.
Although Watermarke offers a larger and more dramatic space, Avenue One may have the more practical gathering area for certain types of parties.
This category ultimately came down to whether you value architectural character or entertaining functionality.
Best Swimming Pool
Our picks: Lexington at Central Park West, Irvine, and Skyline OC, Santa Ana
Edwin selected the main pool at Central Park West for its size, proximity to the fitness center, and surrounding outdoor amenities, including fire pits.
Kathy made a strong case for Skyline OC, highlighting its resort-style atmosphere, spa amenities and attractive pool design.
Watermarke and The Plaza also received honorable mentions for their distinctive pool environments.
If pool size and convenience are your priorities, Lexington has an advantage. If you’re looking for a more dramatic resort-inspired setting, Skyline OC is a strong contender.
Best Views
Our pick: 601 Lido Park Drive, Newport Beach
We ended the showdown with a category where we both agreed.
Skyline OC offers exceptional elevated views, and several Irvine high-rises provide impressive city panoramas. But 601 Lido Park offers something entirely different.
From its residences, owners can enjoy views of Newport Harbor, passing boats, the surrounding coastline and the Pacific Ocean. Even from relatively low floors, the waterfront scenery can be spectacular.
For us, those harbor and ocean views made 601 Lido Park the winner.
Which Orange County Condo Is Best for You?
As our Condo Showdown demonstrates, there isn’t one condominium community that wins every category.
Lexington at Central Park West stood out for walkability, fitness facilities and its swimming pool. Watermarke and Avenue One performed well for affordability and practical amenities. The Plaza impressed us with its penthouse architecture, while Skyline OC earned recognition for its views, resort-style pool and hypothetical zombie survival potential.
Meanwhile, 601 Lido Park Drive demonstrated why Newport Beach waterfront living occupies a different category of luxury condominium lifestyle.
These are our personal selections based on the properties we’ve visited and our experiences showing condos throughout Orange County. Amenities, HOA dues, prices and community conditions can change over time.
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.